🎮 Sell Vintage Toys & Video Games in Milwaukee

Looking to sell vintage toys or video games in Milwaukee? Cream City Pickers buys a wide range of toys, gaming systems, and collectibles from all eras. Whether you have a few items or an entire collection, we offer fast, fair, and local evaluations.
If you’re searching for a place to sell toys or video games near you, we make the process simple and hassle-free.

🧸 We Buy Vintage Toys

We are always looking to purchase vintage toys and collectibles from a wide range of decades, including:

  • 1920s toys
  • 1930s toys
  • 1940s toys
  • 1950s toys
  • 1960s toys
  • 1970s toys
  • 1980s toys
    From tin toys to action figures, we’re interested in a variety of collectible items. If you’re unsure what you have, feel free to reach out, we’re happy to help.

🏭 Popular Toy Brands We Buy

We actively purchase toys from well-known manufacturers, including:

  • Marx
  • Ideal
  • Kenner
  • Buddy L
  • Mattel
  • Deluxe Reading
  • Topper Toys
  • Remco
  • Milton Bradley
  • Hasbro
  • Wham-O
  • Aurora
  • Eldon
  • Kohner
  • Emenee
  • A.C. Gilbert
  • Transogram
    Even if your brand isn’t listed, we may still be interested, just give us a call.

🕹️ We Buy Video Games & Retro Computer Games

We also buy video games and retro computer games, including:

  • Vintage video game systems
  • Cartridge-based games
  • Boxed and complete games
  • Retro computer games
    We are especially interested in original (non-copied) games for systems like:
  • Big Box PC Games from the 1980’s and 1990’s
  • Commodore Amiga
  • Commodore 64
    If you have older games or systems, there’s a good chance we’ll want to take a look.

🔥 1980s Toy Buyers

We LOVE toys from the 1980s, one of the best eras for collectibles. We are actively buying:

  • Action figures
  • Toy lines from the 80s
  • Pop culture collectibles
    Including popular lines like:
  • Transformers
  • G.I. Joe
  • Star Wars
  • Wrestling figures
    Many buyers overlook 80s toys, but we don’t, it was the era we grew up in! We’re always interested in both individual items and full collections.

🗿 We Buy Statues, Busts & Modern Collectibles

We also buy a wide range of statues, busts, and modern collectible toys. From high-end collectible statues to more common pieces, we’re always interested.
Looking to sell your collection of Funko Pop Vinyl figures? We actively buy Funko collections of all sizes.

📦 We Buy Large Toy Collections

We buy almost all old and vintage toys. If you have a collection in your attic, basement, or storage, we’re ready to help.
Whether it’s a few items or a large collection, we make the process easy and offer competitive prices.

📍 Local Toy & Video Game Buyers in Milwaukee

Selling locally has its advantages. When you work with Cream City Pickers, you get:

  • Fast, in-person evaluations
  • No shipping or listing fees
  • Immediate, fair offers
  • A trusted local buyer
    If you’re searching for toy buyers near me or where to sell video games in Milwaukee, we’re here to help.

📞 Ready to Sell Your Toys or Games?

Contact Cream City Pickers today for a fast, no-obligation offer.
Call or text: 201-486-1420
Email: [email protected]

⚠️ Important

We are primarily interested in original toys and video games. We do not purchase copied or reproduction items.

🧸 Vintage Toy Lines We Buy

We are interested in a wide range of vintage toy lines, action figures, and collectibles. If you have items from any of the following, we’d love to hear from you:

🎬 TV, Movie & Pop Culture Toys

  • 007 James Bond Attaché Case
  • 1960s Beatles Toys
  • Green Hornet TV Items
  • Battlestar Galactica Action Figures
  • Buck Rogers
  • Dune
  • Dukes of Hazzard
  • Ewoks
  • Flash Gordon
  • Jurassic Park
  • The Flintstones Building Boulders

🦸 Action Figures & Toy Lines

  • 6 Million Dollar Man
  • The Bionic Woman
  • Big Jim Action Figures
  • Blackstar
  • Bravestarr
  • Dino Riders
  • Dragonriders of the Styx
  • Earth Force
  • Inhumanoids
  • M.A.S.K. / MASK by Kenner
  • Masters of the Universe (MOTU)
  • G.I. Joe Items

🤖 Robots, Sci-Fi & Japanese Toys

  • Diakron Transformers
  • Diaclone Transformers
  • GoBots
  • Godaikin (Popy, Bandai, Voltes V, Takatoku, Daltanias, God Mars, Chogokin, Golion, Combattra, Tetsujin 28)
  • Johnny Astro
  • Firebird 99

🏎️ Diecast, Vehicles & Slot Cars

  • Hot Wheels
  • Hot Wheels Redline
  • Matchbox Cars
  • Lesney
  • Aurora Thunderjet Slot Cars
  • Corgi
  • Crashmobile
  • Crusader 101 Car

🏭 Classic Toy Brands & Manufacturers

  • Aurora Models
  • Ideal Toys
  • Kenner
  • Marx Playsets
  • Mattel
  • Remco
  • Wham-O
  • Deluxe Reading
  • Hartland Plastics

🧸 Dolls, Plush & Character Toys

  • Barbie
  • Blythe Doll by Kenner
  • Flatsy Dolls
  • Little Kiddles
  • Kamar Plush Stuffed Animals
  • Gumby
  • Casper

🎲 Games, Novelty & Unique Toys

  • Clackers / Click Clacks / Klackers
  • Cootie Game
  • Crazy Clock Game by Ideal
  • Lemon Twist
  • Ker-Knockers
  • Jarts
  • Fuzzy Wuzzy Soap
  • Magic Window by Wham-O

🚀 Space, Military & Adventure Toys

  • Major Matt Mason
  • Johnny Eagle Guns
  • Johnny Reb Toy Cannon
  • Mattel M-16 Marauder Toy Gun
  • Jet Fighter by Ideal
  • Jimmy Jet TV Jet

🧠 Rare, Obscure & Collector Toys

  • Billy Blastoff
  • Great Garloo Robot
  • King Zor
  • Hugo: Man of a Thousand Faces
  • Defender Dan
  • Gaylord the Dog
  • Clancy the Roller Skating Chimp

🧱 Building Toys & Creative Play

  • LEGO Toys
  • LEGO Star Wars
  • LEGO Toy Story
  • Vintage LEGO Blocks
  • Kenner Girder & Panel Building Sets
  • Magnetic Doll House “Thimble City”

🎯 More Vintage & Hard-to-Find Toys

  • Air Blaster Gun
  • Agent Zero M Toys
  • Battle Action by Ideal
  • Blaze Ride-On Toys
  • Bugmen of Insecta
  • Coney Island Penny Machine by Remco
  • Control Line Planes by Aurora Cox
  • Easy Show
  • Fantasy World
  • Flying Fox
  • Furby
  • Give-A-Show
  • Inchworm by Hasbro
  • Krazy Kar
  • Mary Mag Powers / Child Guidance

If you don’t see your items listed here, don’t worry, we buy a wide variety of vintage toys and collectibles. There’s a good chance we’re still interested.

🧸 More Vintage Toy Lines We Buy

We are always looking to purchase additional vintage toys, action figures, and collectible toy lines. If you have any of the following, we’re interested:

🦸 Action Figures & Popular Toy Lines

  • Mego (Planet of the Apes, Marvel Superheroes, Action Jackson, Star Trek, World’s Greatest Superheroes, Bend N Flex, Dinah-Mite, KISS, Flash Gordon)
  • Micronauts
  • Mighty Morphin Power Rangers
  • Monster in My Pocket
  • My Pet Monster
  • Power Lords
  • Robo Force
  • Robot Defenders & Robot Renegades
  • Robotech
  • Rock Lords
  • Secret Wars
  • Sectaurs
  • Silverhawks
  • Starcom
  • Star Wars (Kenner)
  • Super Powers (Kenner)
  • Transformers
  • Thundercats
  • Voltron
  • World’s Greatest Super Heroes

🤖 Robots, Sci-Fi & Electronic Toys

  • Rock’em Sock’em Robots
  • Zeroids Robots (Zintar, Zogg, etc.)
  • Thinkatron
  • Tiger Handheld Games
  • Vertibird
  • Vintage Mr. Machine

🧸 Dolls, Plush & Character Toys

  • Mattel Pull String Talking Dolls
  • Mrs. Beasley
  • Tammy Doll by Ideal
  • Teddy Ruxpin & Grubby
  • Trolls / Wishnik Dolls
  • Zippy the Monkey

🎲 Games, Novelties & Classic Toys

  • Mouse Trap
  • Silly Putty
  • Silly Sand
  • Slinky
  • Superball
  • Think-A-Dot Computer Game
  • Slide Puzzles
  • Yo-Yos

🚗 Vehicles, Playsets & Mechanical Toys

  • Motorific Cars & Boats by Ideal
  • SSP Cars by Kenner
  • Pan Am Dual Control Cockpit
  • Whee-lo
  • Tigeroo Bike Growler

Toy Soldiers & Military Toys

  • Toy Soldiers (Manoil, Barclay, Britains Ltd., Marx, Lead Soldiers, Cowboys & Indians, Tootsie Toy)
  • Remco Monkey Division & Guerrilla Warfare Toys

🎭 Creative, Educational & Specialty Toys

  • Thingmaker Sets
  • Strange Change Machine
  • Suzy Homemaker
  • Toonykins by Ideal
  • Tree Tots by Kenner

🎬 TV, Movie & Licensed Toys

  • Batman (1960s collectibles)
  • Thunderbirds
  • Thomas the Tank Engine / Thomas & Friends Wooden Toys
  • Skylanders (all series, new or used)

🎯 Vintage & Unique Collectibles

  • Old Red Raven Magic Movie Mirror & Records
  • Pez
  • Playmobil
  • Push Puppet Toys
  • Rat Fink Toys
  • Screen-A-Show
  • Show ‘N Tell
  • Spy Toys
  • Stretch Armstrong & Stretch Monster
  • Target Games (Vintage)
  • Tickle Bee
  • Tony the Pony

🧠 Rare, Obscure & Hard-to-Find Toys

  • Mignot Toy Soldiers & Models
  • Models & Trading Cards
  • Nutty Mads
  • Odd Ogg
  • Orby
  • Pocket Super Heroes
  • Shogun-style / Japanese imports
  • Zany and novelty toys from all eras

🕰️ 1960s & Classic Vintage Toys

  • Vintage 1960s Monster Toys
  • Vintage NY Mets & Mr. Met Items
  • Vintage Colorforms
  • Vintage Vari-Vue Flicker Rings
  • Weebles

If you don’t see your items listed here, don’t worry, we buy a wide variety of vintage toys and collectibles from all eras. There’s a strong chance we’re still interested in your items.

🎮 We Buy Video Games & Retro Gaming Systems

Looking to sell video games in Milwaukee? Cream City Pickers buys video games, consoles, accessories, and gaming collections from all eras. Whether you have a single system or an entire collection, we offer fast, fair, and local evaluations.
If you’re searching for a place to sell video games near you, we make the process easy and hassle-free.

🕹️ We Buy All Video Game Systems

We buy all video game systems, vintage, retro, and modern, including:

🎯 Classic & Retro Systems

  • Atari 2600, 2600 Jr., 2800, 5200, 7800
  • Coleco & ColecoVision
  • Vectrex
  • Intellivision

🍄 Nintendo Systems

  • Nintendo Game & Watch
  • Nintendo Entertainment System (NES)
  • Super Nintendo (SNES)
  • Nintendo 64
  • Nintendo GameCube
  • Nintendo Game Boy, Game Boy Color, Game Boy Advance
  • Nintendo DS, 3DS, 3DS XL
  • Virtual Boy

🔵 Sega Systems

  • Sega Master System
  • Sega Genesis
  • Sega CD
  • Sega 32X
  • Sega Saturn

⚡ Other Retro & Specialty Systems

  • TurboGrafx-16
  • TurboDuo
  • Neo Geo (CD, CDZ)
  • PC-FX
  • CD-i
  • 3DO
  • Atari Jaguar & Jaguar CD

🎮 Modern Consoles

  • Sony PlayStation, PlayStation 2, PlayStation 3
  • Microsoft Xbox, Xbox 360

📦 What Video Game Items We Buy

We are interested in all types of gaming-related items, including:

  • Video game consoles
  • Game cartridges and discs
  • Controllers and accessories
  • Boxed and complete games
  • Gaming merchandise and collectibles
    Whether your items are loose, boxed, or part of a larger collection, we’re interested.

💰 Sell Your Video Games for Cash in Milwaukee

We LOVE video games and are always looking to buy collections of all sizes. Many buyers overlook older systems, but we actively seek them out.
If you’re searching for sell video games near me, retro game buyers Milwaukee, or where to sell old video games, Cream City Pickers is your trusted local buyer.

📞 Ready to Sell Your Video Games?

Contact us today for a fast, no-obligation offer.
Call or text: 201-486-1420
Email: [email protected]

🛍️ We Buy More Than Just Military Collectibles

In addition to militaria, we also buy a wide range of collectibles including vintage toys and collectibles, comic book collections, and vintage costume jewelry.

⚠️ Important

We are primarily interested in original video games and systems. We do not purchase copied or reproduction games.