Sell Your Vintage Costume Jewelry – Anywhere in the USA

Have a jewelry box full of vintage necklaces, brooches, bracelets, earrings, or rings? Cream City Pickers buys vintage costume jewelry from individuals, families, and estates across the United States.

Your collection doesn’t need to be sorted. We welcome inquiries about signed and unsigned pieces, mixed collections, inherited jewelry, and pieces with damage or missing parts. Send us photos and a brief description to get started.

Meet Lou, the Person Behind Cream City Pickers

Get to know Lou in this interview filmed during his Bergen Pickers days. Today, he operates Cream City Pickers in Milwaukee, buying vintage toys, costume jewelry, antiques, and collectibles from sellers across the USA.

How Our Mail-In Buying Process Works

  1. Contact us first. Call or text 201-486-1420, or fill out our website’s contact form. We’ll discuss your collection and arrange shipping before you send anything.
  2. Send your collection. We cover shipping costs up to $30, with details agreed upon before shipment.
  3. Receive an offer. We review your items the day they arrive and make an offer based on what we expect to resell them for.
  4. Choose whether to accept. If you accept, we send payment promptly through Venmo, PayPal, Zelle, or by check, whichever you prefer.
  5. Decline without pressure. If you decline our offer, we ship your items back at no cost to you.

Sell Your Jewelry Locally in Milwaukee & Surrounding Areas

Prefer to sell in person? We come to you! Cream City Pickers offers convenient, appointment-based visits throughout Milwaukee and surrounding communities.

We’ll review your jewelry, make a no-obligation offer, and pay cash on the spot if you accept. No packing or shipping needed.

Call or text 201-486-1420, or fill out our contact form to tell us about your collection and schedule a visit.

What Local Sellers Say

“Lou is a very friendly and honest person! He gave a fair offer on the items that he bought.”

— Randall Edgar, Google review · Read review

“He was genuine, honest and educated. I will hopefully have more business dealings with Lou in the future and recommend him without any reservations to anyone looking to buy or sell the items he deals with.”

— Susan August, Google review about selling toys · Read review

Ready to Sell Your Jewelry?

Call or text 201-486-1420, or use our contact form to tell us about your collection. Include photos, your state, and an approximate number of pieces if possible.

Please contact us before shipping any items.

We don’t care if the items aren’t sorted or some are damaged. Anything we can’t use, we usually pass on to local hobbyists or artists. In addition to jewelry, we also buy trading cards and sports cards, vintage toys, comic books, and so much more!

 

Have old costume jewelry, but live out of state? No problem! We take out of state orders. Contact us at [email protected] and we will give you easy instructions on sending us your items. If you have questions, feel free to call 201-486-1420!

Vintage Costume Jewelry buyers, jewelry buyers, Milwaukee WI, Wisconsin, vintage jewelry,

⌚ Sell Vintage Watches in Milwaukee

Looking to sell vintage watches in Milwaukee? Cream City Pickers buys antique watches, pocket watches, and wristwatches in all conditions. Whether you have a high-end luxury piece or an everyday brand, we offer fast, fair, and local evaluations.
If you’re searching for a place to sell watches near you, we make the process simple and hassle-free.

💰 We Buy Watches in All Conditions

We are always interested in purchasing:

  • Vintage wristwatches
  • Antique pocket watches
  • Railroad watches
  • Luxury and designer watches
  • Everyday brands and collectible pieces
    Working or not, complete or partial—we’re happy to take a look.

🏷️ Watch Brands We Buy

We regularly purchase watches from brands including:

  • Rolex
  • Omega
  • Patek Philippe
  • Cartier
  • Breitling
  • Tag Heuer
  • Hublot
  • Longines
  • Hamilton
  • Wittnauer
  • Bulova
  • Benrus
  • Waltham & Co.
  • Elgin
  • Seiko
  • Citizen
  • Bulgari
    If your brand isn’t listed, don’t worry, we buy a wide variety of vintage and antique watches.

📍 Local Watch Buyers in Milwaukee

Selling locally has its advantages. When you work with Cream City Pickers, you get:

  • Fast, in-person evaluations
  • No shipping or fees
  • Immediate, fair offers
  • A trusted local buyer
    If you’re searching for watch buyers near me or where to sell vintage watches in Milwaukee, we’re here to help.

📞 Ready to Sell Your Watch?

Call or text: 201-486-1420
Email: [email protected]
Contact us today for a fast, no-obligation offer.

⚠️ Important

We are interested in original watches only. We do not purchase knockoffs or replicas.