🛍️ What We Buy in Milwaukee
Here at Cream City Pickers, we buy a wide range of vintage toys, collectibles, antiques, and memorabilia. If you’re looking to sell collectibles in Milwaukee, we offer fast, fair, and local evaluations.
Below are some of the most common items we purchase. If you don’t see your item listed, give us a call, we may still be interested.
🧸 Toys, Toy Cars & Collectibles
We buy all types of vintage toys and collectible items, including:
- Toy cars (Hot Wheels, Redline, Matchbox, Lesney, Corgi, TootsieToy, Arcade, Marx, Buddy L)
- Action figures and vintage toy lines
- Toy robots (Godaikin, Chogokin, Voltron, Transformers, GoBots, Japanese tin toys)
- Barbie and dolls (pre-1970 preferred)
- American Girl dolls and accessories
- Vintage board games and character games
- Tin toys, wind-up toys, and cast iron toys
- Lunch boxes and thermos sets
Coins, Currency & Stamps
We are always looking to buy:
- Coins (antique, vintage, U.S. and foreign)
- Paper currency
- Stamp collections (U.S. and foreign, early 1900s and older)
- Cigarette cards and cigar cards
📚 Comic Books & Paper Collectibles
We purchase:
- Comic books (1970s and older preferred)
- Original comic art
- Pulps, horror magazines, and vintage publications
- Comic Con exclusives (SDCC, NYCC, etc.)
- Antique books, signed books, and limited editions
- Sheet music and early printed materials
🃏 Trading Cards & Sports Collectibles
We buy:
- Trading cards (Topps, Wacky Packages, Garbage Pail Kids, non-sports cards)
- Baseball, football, basketball, and sports cards
- Vintage card collections and sets
- Cigar cards and gum cards
🎮 Video Games & Electronics
We buy:
- Retro video games and systems (Nintendo, Sega, Game Boy, etc.)
- Arcade machines and pinball machines
- Vintage electronic collectibles
🎵 Vinyl Records & Music Memorabilia
We are interested in:
- Vinyl records (LPs, 45s, record collections)
- Vintage concert posters and band t-shirts
- Music memorabilia and collectibles
- Instruments (guitars, violins, flutes, trumpets, banjos, and more)
🎬 Movie, TV & Pop Culture Memorabilia
We buy:
- Movie posters and lobby cards
- TV and film collectibles
- Star Wars and Star Trek memorabilia
- Vintage TV merchandise (1960s–1970s)
🎖️ Military, Historical & Political Items
We purchase:
- Military collectibles (Civil War, WWI, WWII, Vietnam, etc.)
- Uniforms, medals, field gear, and weapons
- Election memorabilia (pins, buttons, badges, signed items)
- Early Boy Scout and Girl Scout items
🏭 Advertising, Signs & Vintage Items
We are always buying:
- Vintage signs (oil & gas, store signs, advertising)
- Coca-Cola and soda advertising memorabilia
- Gas pumps and automotive signs
- Old neon signs and display items
🧰 Antiques, Tools & Miscellaneous Collectibles
We also buy a wide range of unique items, including:
- Vintage auto parts and hubcaps
- Fishing lures and outdoor collectibles
- Matchbooks and vintage lighters (Zippo, Ronson, Dunhill)
- Watches and clocks (non-gold included)
- Pens, fountain pens, and writing instruments
- Bottles, ink wells, and antique containers
- Small vending machines and soda dispensers
- Antique telephones and electronics
🎯 Specialty & Niche Collectibles
We are interested in many niche items, including:
- Railroad lamps
- Circus and carnival memorabilia
- Route 66 memorabilia
- NASA collectibles
- Vintage diner collectibles
- Halloween and Christmas collectibles
- Vintage ephemera (letters, postcards, scrapbooks, WWII letters)
- Taxidermy and unique display items
📞 Ready to Sell Your Items?
If you’re looking to sell collectibles, antiques, or vintage items, Cream City Pickers is ready to help.
Call or text: 201-486-1420
Email: [email protected]
Contact us today for a fast, no-obligation offer.
🛍️ We Buy More Than Just Military Collectibles
In addition to militaria, we also buy a wide range of collectibles including vintage toys and collectibles, comic book collections, and vintage costume jewelry.